| Platinum | Casa Manana |
| Gold | Laguna's Mexican Grill Catina |
| Silver | Que Pasa Taqueria |
| Bronze | Casa, Manana |
| Top Pick | Casa Ole' |
| Top Pick | Chili's Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | El Dorado Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Johnny Sanchez |
| Top Pick | Mexican Restaurant, El Tapatio |
| Top Pick | Tia Juanitas Fish Camp |